“This week Caroline Lucas MP uttered a profound sentence as she was being arrested for protesting against fracking in Southern England this week. “Fracking is the dying breaths from the fossil fuels industry” she said whilst debating the issue.”As someone who can understand both sides of the great fracking debate currently gripping the nation at the moment, I can see a nation wrestling with its own conscience.
For those who watch the news and see protesters passionately making their voices and views heard reminds me of the fuel protests of 2005. Both are consequences, or as I call them first tremors, of a much larger danger called peak oil. A Pompeian style disaster looming over the whole world and like the Pompeians, the danger can be seen every day, but largely ignored or misunderstood.
Protesters who gather at anti-fracking demonstrations are on the whole, attempting to stop the energy industries from extracting another form of CO2 which would exacerbate the global heating problem.
On the other hand, you have the energy companies who are finally beginning to take the problem of peak oil and who are desperate to find additional sources of hydrocarbons to keep our modern civilisation functioning in a time where oil production is plateauing and declining globally.
The best description I have heard about the process of dying is that it feels ‘panicky’, and you can certainly see panic with huge financial subsidies being spent on developing the last ‘uneconomical’ smaller pockets of North Sea resources and destructive Shale Gas locally.
Global desperation for new sources of hydrocarbons can be seen with Canada’s tar sands operations currently experiencing similar protesting going on in the US. Protesting is also going on in Australia, South America’s Amazon and Arctic regions to name only a few, so the increasingly desperate search for alternative fossil fuels by the world’s energy companies should be a warning to us all.
And as the Americans are now discovering with their fracking revolution, like all over revolutions, the outcome is not as great as first hoped. Fracking wells which have been drilled have a failure rate of around 50%. Of those successful wells, the economic lifespan is only around 12 months. The long-term economic viability of shale gas extraction is very short, meaning continued well drilling is required to keep production to peak levels and again without huge subsidies the operations are actually uneconomical.
The costs of continually drilling for short-term benefits will be costly, economically and environmentally, but fracking will undoubtedly continue because there is no other alternative.
The protesting we see around the world may not be a debate, but humanities conscious wrestling with itself.
The green movement has lost, but will be replaced by the energy conservation movement
Two years ago I declared that the green movement had failed, and the hope that humans would turn the huge global warming problem around before we reached the point of no-return, was for me a very low point.
However, what I now believe, is that any green transition will be an unintended consequence of unavoidable energy costs. The energy giants may still be leaving no stone unturned in their quest for continued profit, but the stones will gradually get smaller and smaller.
However, reluctant, people may not be able to ‘save the planet’, but the enthusiasm to save energy, or more to the point, save money on increasing energy costs will continue to build momentum year on year.
This world of unintended consequences, will continue to unravel as climate problems will continue unabated to cause crop failures around the world with food prices causing social unrest for many unstable governments. We can already see this beginning to happen with last year’s Arab Spring as economic and climatic related hardships begin to bite around the world.
A downturn in global food production, will run alongside a downturn in oil production which will only exacerbate our problems. Fracking can at best, only prop-up the transition period and not reverse the trend. Next decades energy bills of even the middle classes will become uncomfortably expensive as the working class struggle to heat their homes.
Only last week, I said to my baby son whilst whisking him around a typical supermarket that he should appreciate these times because when he is my older, the shelves will be very much emptier than you see them today.
The energy conservation movement will become the change in people’s attitudes towards burning fossil fuels that the green movement failed to achieve, although through necessity and not through a desire to be green.
"Feel the pride."
Stuart Lovatt on
Founder of Heat My Home.